Parenting and Family
What if parents feel caring but children do not feel cared for?
English translation draft · Based on the Chinese article. This is not a word-for-word translation approved by Master Shengyuan.
When parents feel they care deeply but their children do not feel that care, sometimes the two generations have different experiences and ways of expressing themselves. The same situation may therefore be received differently. I heard a story about a mother who feared her child might have an accident crossing the road. She repeatedly described how frightening being hit and bleeding would be, and the child became persistently afraid to cross. This is a story I heard, reminding us that caring words may also carry our own fears; it does not mean traffic safety is unimportant. Of course, some parents really did give too little care at the time. Not every situation can be explained as a child’s misunderstanding.
Care is more than providing money. A child may want conversation, someone alongside while doing homework, or interest in school. Speaking about discomfort takes courage, and adults need to notice when children cannot speak. Only mutual willingness to understand can bring problems into conversation, rather than treating our own views as the answer. Different generations face matters differently, so do not merely call children unable to handle pressure. A loud voice does not necessarily mean hostility, but real hurt cannot be dismissed by saying it was all love. Understanding does not mean unlimited indulgence. It means listening carefully and facing things together.
As a child, I also found my parents nagging and controlling. Stepping back, however, I could see that their basic position was concern. I have shared an example with clients: a high-school student stays awake secretly playing games on a phone. Worried about getting up the next day and damage to eyesight, parents scold and repeatedly nag. The child is unhappy, resists, and argues. Our advice to such families is to avoid confrontational language before the conversation even begins. Parents may be motivated by love, but an unsuitable tone and attitude can leave a child feeling restricted.
As a father, I also ask whether my children feel that I will listen, genuinely care, and willingly spend time with them. This needs gradual building through action. Bringing money home matters, but without time together the child may not receive the intention behind it.
Arranging many classes does not necessarily amount to companionship, and leaving everything alone does not necessarily make a child feel loved. Understand their interests and what suits them, and ask whether you face things alongside them. Many demands alone do not establish unhappiness; granting freedom alone does not establish that respect is complete. We still need to understand actual feelings.
Love can also be expressed openly. I rarely hugged my parents when young. Fatherhood and cultivation gradually helped me learn to show affection. Neo said he hugs me and touches heads with me every day. Yet in that same conversation, Qian Qian said she could not stand her father and brother continually hugging and kissing her. We cannot assume she enjoys it simply because of our interpretation. Respect each other and discuss timing where cooperation is needed, rather than doing only what we like.
A friend’s child kept taking leave and did not want school. Asking teachers had not confirmed bullying. The father eventually chose to talk from the child’s position, recognizing that continual scolding might make disclosure harder. The child had not returned to school then, but some interaction and communication had become happier. This was gradual exploration, not everything solved in one conversation or proof that every school refusal involves bullying.
Miao Li shared a capable mother who worked hard to provide a good life but struggled with her child gradually ignoring her. Discussion revealed that mother and child rarely spent time alone together. Miao Li reminded her that looking like an adult does not remove a need for mother. Moved, she was willing to rearrange time. This was a case Miao Li explored through written-character divination, not a single explanation for every quiet child.
I then said that work and income have real demands, but we can consider reserving a family day or half a holiday for focused time together. Sometimes a child wants holding hands, walking, and talking rather than another class. Parents’ belief that they give love and the child’s felt experience still need to be understood through interaction.
Sometimes one action communicates recognition. When YOYO went home, she found her father showing his elementary-school classmates videos of her program and introducing his daughter’s work. She felt that willingness showed acknowledgment and pride. Smiling outwardly, she was moved almost to tears. That was her experience of care, reminding us that support need not stay hidden inside; action can make it visible.
Watching It Comes, I noticed a contrast in the fictional father. Family photographs on his blog made him look devoted, but his actual response to his daughter did not show equivalent concern. This film prompted me to distinguish a family-loving image from care family members genuinely receive. Love they can feel still grows through companionship and time together.